6 The business of RecSys: how platforms make money
Online platforms often look free or simple on the surface, but their real business depends heavily on recommender systems. These systems help platforms decide what content, products, or people to show, and that ranking power is tied to how money is made. In subscription services, recommendations keep users engaged so they renew. In commerce, they help people discover items they might not have found on their own, increasing purchases. In marketplaces, they help match buyers and sellers, while the platform takes a cut of each transaction. In ad-supported services, they keep people on the platform longer and make them more valuable to advertisers.
What makes recommendations especially profitable is that they do more than help users find relevant things: they shape behavior. Platforms use them to encourage extra spending, boost engagement, and steer users toward actions that serve the platform’s financial goals. This can create feedback loops where already popular items or accounts keep getting more visibility, making it harder for newer or smaller players to compete. In two-sided markets, the platform is not just ordering choices but actively managing work, demand, and supply, often with little transparency for workers or sellers. As a result, the recommender system becomes a key tool for controlling liquidity, demand, and market access.
The chapter also shows that advertising-based platforms rely on extensive surveillance. To target ads effectively, they collect data from browsing, purchases, location, and other online behavior, often across websites and devices through cookies and data brokers. This enables highly specific profiling and real-time ad auctions, but it also raises serious privacy concerns. Promoted content further blurs the line between organic recommendations and paid placement, reducing transparency and sometimes weakening democratic scrutiny. Overall, the chapter argues that recommender systems are not neutral helpers: they are central to how platforms monetize attention, extract data, and combine multiple revenue streams to maximize profit.
Summary
Recommender systems play a prominent role in generating revenue on platforms and transforming them into multi-billion-dollar businesses.
When platforms charge a fee or subscription to access their services—common in on-demand streaming services—recommender systems are tasked to keep paying users interested with novel content so that they will renew their subscriptions.
Recommender can suggest other items to buy, in e-commerce platforms—whose inventory is so vast that manual browsing would be impossible
Recommender systems facilitate connecting goods and services and platforms take a cut of any transaction as is coming in ride-hailing, hotel-booking, or freelance worker marketplaces.
The most pervasive business model of platforms is, however, the attention economy, in which platforms offer incentives to keep users online for as long as possible for two interconnected reasons: to display revenue-generating content and to profile users.
Revenue-generating content typically comes in two formats: ads and promoted content. Ads are the most versatile—and the most scrutinized—format, in which someone pays the platform to reach a specific goal, such as visibility or installation of new apps. On the other hand, promoted content refers to existing content whose visibility has been artificially boosted. While more limited in format and scope, it also undergoes less scrutiny from outside parties, yet its effects should not be minimized.
FAQ
How do online platforms make money when users do not pay a subscription fee?Platforms that do not charge users directly often rely on advertising, promoted content, transaction fees, or other monetization methods. In these cases, the platform earns revenue by attracting attention, facilitating sales, or charging sellers and advertisers rather than end users.Why are recommender systems so important in subscription-based platforms?On subscription platforms, recommender systems help users find content they enjoy, which increases satisfaction and makes them more likely to keep renewing their subscriptions. In that sense, recommendations help retain users over the long term.Why does the book say that “the recommendations are the product” on services like Netflix?Because if users cannot easily find appealing content, they may assume the platform has nothing worthwhile to offer and cancel their subscription. Good recommendations are therefore not just a feature; they are central to what users are paying for.How do recommender systems help platforms increase transaction volume?They suggest additional or complementary items that users may not have thought to buy, such as “People who bought this also bought that.” This can increase sales by encouraging upselling and cross-selling.What is a profit-cut business model in online marketplaces?In a profit-cut model, the platform takes a fee from transactions it facilitates, either as a fixed amount or as a percentage of the sale. This is common in ride-hailing, vacation rentals, freelance marketplaces, and online booking services.What is the attention economy, and how do recommender systems support it?The attention economy is a business model where platforms profit from the time and attention users spend on them. Recommender systems support it by keeping users engaged longer, which increases the chances they will interact with ads or other revenue-generating content.Why is advertising considered a surveillance-based business model in this chapter?Because effective ad targeting depends on collecting detailed information about users’ behavior, interests, and demographics. Platforms gather this data through interactions, cookies, tracking, and profiling, then use it to sell more precise and valuable ads.How do cookies help platforms track users across the internet?Cookies store data in the browser and can remember actions like logins or shopping-cart contents. Third-party cookies can also follow browsing activity across different websites, allowing platforms and advertisers to build broader behavioral profiles.What are promoted posts, and how are they different from regular ads?Promoted posts are regular pieces of content that creators or businesses pay to boost in visibility. Compared with traditional ads, they often have fewer targeting and formatting options, but they blend more easily into organic content.Why do platforms often combine multiple business models?Because combining models lets platforms create several revenue streams at once, such as subscriptions, transaction fees, ads, promoted content, and data collection. This mixture can also blur the lines for users, making it harder to tell what is organic, sponsored, or monetized in another way.
pro $24.99 per month
access to all Manning books, MEAPs, liveVideos, liveProjects, and audiobooks!